2021 Minutes
Minutes of the AGM of the English Orienteering Council
held via Zoom
on Thursday 27th May 2021
Present
| EOC Officials | |
|---|---|
| Barry Elkington | Chair |
| Lesley Ross | Treasurer |
| Scott Collier | Secretary |
| John Rye | Interland Team Manager |
| Voting Association Representatives | |
|---|---|
| Christine Vince | SWOA |
| Jon Wheatcroft | SCOA |
| Simon Greenwood | SEOA |
| Richard Lewis | WMOA |
| Ann-Marie Duckworth | EMOA |
| Peter Woods | EAOA |
| Debby Warren | NEOA |
| Actions: | Responsible: |
|---|---|
| Association representatives to communicate the 2021 financial contribution levels back to their Associations. | Association representatives |
| The Chair to write to Mike Cope (Chair of British Orienteering Event Scheduling Group) proposing that the Interland TM work with ESG to agree a rota in which the English Associations would commit to hosting five Home Internationals in four years, having regard to the difference in terrain availability in the different English regions. | Chair |
| The Secretary to forward an email from Duncan Archer (Orienteering Foundation Trustee) to Simon Greenwood (SEOA) regarding the possibility of bidding for funding to subsidise the 2021 JHI. | Secretary |
The meeting commenced at 7:30 pm.
Apologies
Apologies were received from
Charlie Adams (Senior Team Manager)
Mel Elkington (Welfare Officer & Kit Officer)
Andy Hemsted (Chair, Veteran Selectors)
Keith & Sue Marsden (Chairs, Junior Selectors).
Adoption of the 2020 AGM minutes
No comments were made, and none had been received in advance of the meeting. Adoption of the minutes of the 2020 AGM was proposed by Simon Greenwood (SEOA), seconded by Peter Woods (EAOA), and carried nem con.
Ann-Marie Duckworth (EMOA) joined the meeting at this point.
Chair’s report
The Chair began by welcoming attendees to the virtual meeting, and noted that it was pleasing to see such good Regional representation again.
The Chair informed the meeting that, in his first year as Chair, nothing had happened – apart from a pandemic. As a result, all three Home Internationals had been cancelled, as well as the Interland trip to Belgium.
On a more positive note, the Chair thanked the Interland TM for persevering with his work on the thorny issue of the Home International rota, which was on the agenda for later in the meeting.
The Chair concluded with hopes that he would have rather more to report on in twelve months’ time, and looked forward to a successful year for all England teams.
Adoption of the 2020 financial accounts
The statement of accounts for 2020 and a forecast for 2021 had been circulated ahead of the meeting. The 2020 accounts had been reviewed by Trevor Simpson of WMOA. The Chair thanked the Treasurer for her work in preparing these accounts.
The Interland TM indicated that although the figures in the accounts for Interland 2020 appeared large, this was in fact the result of income from foreign teams matched by expenditure on their behalf.
The adoption of the 2020 accounts was proposed by Lesley Ross (Treasurer), seconded by Simon Greenwood (SCOA), and carried nem con.
Appointment of a reviewer for the 2021 financial accounts
Paul Young, the EMOA Treasurer, had kindly volunteered to review 2021 accounts ahead of the 2022 AGM, and was appointed nem con.
Approval of the Association financial contributions for 2021
The Treasurer recommended that the Association financial contribution for 2021 be set at 75p per head.
Simon Greenwood (SEOA) asked when the figures for membership used to calculate the contribution were taken, and the Treasurer indicated that this was usually in June or July.
Simon Greenwood (SEOA) noted that SEOA membership numbers had begun to increase now that events had restarted. The Secretary indicated that this reflected the national picture.
The recommended contributions proposed by Jon Wheatcroft (SCOA), seconded by Peter Woods (EAOA), and agreed nem con.
The Chair requested that Association representatives communicate the 2021 contribution levels back to their Associations.
Action: Association representatives
England Orienteering kit
The Secretary read out a report on behalf of the Kit Office. This indicated that EOC held a good level of kit in stock and that it was unlikely that any additional stocks would need to be purchased in 2021.
Since the previous AGM, the EOC has sold 16 O-tops, 14 hoodies, one t-shirt and eight technical t-shirts, mostly at Interland, as this was the only competition that took place in 2020.
The previous supplier of hoodies and technical t-shirts was no longer able to print kit, but the Kit Officer had found another supplier who could produce the same design at a reasonable cost.
An additional stock of England badges had been purchased and the EOC now held a good level of stock.
The Chair noted that kit distribution at Interland had been efficient.
Election of officers
The Chair and the Secretary indicated that they were both content to continue in post.
The Treasurer had previously indicated that she intended to stand down. Harriet Lawson (WMOA), who is a qualified accountant, had kindly agreed to take over as Treasurer.
The Chair thanked Lesley Ross for her many years of effort as EOC Treasurer.
Barry Elkington (WMOA) was proposed as Chair, Scott Collier (SWOA) as Secretary and Harriet Lawson (WMOA) as Treasurer. The appointments were proposed by the current Treasurer, seconded by Ann-Marie Duckworth (EMOA), and carried nem con.
Appointment of Selectors, Team Managers, and other officials
All other officials had agreed to continue in post, and their reappointment was approved nem con.
Home International hosting rota
- The Chair set out the results of discussions with the other Home Nations since the previous AGM:
- Neither Northern Ireland nor Wales were able to host three events in four years and wished to drop to two in four years
- This left eight events in a four-year period to be split between England and Scotland
- Scotland were not willing to increase from their current three events in four years
- This would leave the English regions to host five events in four years
Christine Vince (SWOA) noted the difficulties that SWOA (and other regions) had been experiencing in obtaining landowner permissions, and felt unable to commit to hosting additional events at the current time.
Simon Greenwood (SEOA) noted that it was often difficult to find suitable terrain in SEOA for Home Internationals at the specified time of year, and indicated that greater flexibility in the scheduling might make this easier.
The Interland TM noted that the Home Internationals had historically been held in the autumn, that a previous attempt to move the SHI to the spring had been unsuccessful, and that there was a need to deconflict both the SHI and JHI with other international commitments and with exams.
The Interland TM further noted that England hosting five Home Internationals in four years would equate to each English region hosting one Home International every seven or eight years.
Peter Woods (EAOA) indicated that, while EAOA had suitable terrain to host the JHI, they would struggle to find suitable areas for the SHI or VHI. The Interland TM confirmed that the current rota took this into account.
Ann-Marie Duckworth noted that vegetation meant that EMOA terrain was not suitable for hosting significant events in the autumn, and that EMOA were also facing difficulty in securing landowner permissions.
Harriet Lawson (Treasurer Elect) joined the meeting at this point. The Chair welcomed her to the meeting.
Debby Warren (NEOA) noted the relative shortage of volunteers available to assist with staging events in NEOA. The Interland TM indicated that this would be taken into account in the rota.
The Chair proposed that the English Associations commit to hosting five Home Internationals in four years, and the Interland TM should work with the British Orienteering Event Scheduling Group, chaired by Mike Cope, to develop a rota which would have regard to the difference in terrain availability in the different English regions.
It was agreed nem con that the Chair should write to Mike Cope.
Action: Chair
Interland 2022
Interland 2022 was due to be hosted in southern Belgium in March 2022. Whether an England team would be able to attend would be dependent on the Covid situation at that time, which could not be predicted. The EOC would be required to commit a deposit in advance, and that money may be lost if Covid restrictions meant that it was not viable to send an England team.
The Interland TM indicated that travel may be a challenge given the likely requirement for multi-occupancy vehicles, and that there may also be issues with identifying suitable selection events.
The Chaired thanked the Interland TM for the excellent work that he had done in maintaining good relationships with the European federations while avoiding any loss of EOC funds in relation to the cancelled Interland 2021.
Ann-Maire Duckworth (EMOA) suggested that the EOC should hold a further meeting later in the year to discuss Interland.
The Chair suggested that the meeting could ask the Interland TM to explore travel and accommodation preferences with individuals who may be candidates for selection.
Peter Woods (EAOA) noted that, if money was not spent on Interland, it would not be spent on anything else, and noted the potential impact of a further cancellation on junior athletes who had already missed a year of competition.
The meeting agreed nem con to delegate authority to the Interland TM to decide, in consultation with the EOC officers, whether and when to expend EOC funds on advance costs for Interland 2022.
AOB
Simon Greenwood (SEOA) raised the possibility of seeking financial support from the Orienteering Foundation to subsidise the costs of the 2021 JHI. The Secretary offered to forward an email from Duncan Archer (Orienteering Foundation Trustee) setting out what sort of bid would be most likely to secure funding.
Action: Secretary
The Chair raised the nature of the relationship between EOC and British Orienteering. The Secretary explained that British Orienteering was reviewing the nature of its relationship with clubs and associations, and that the relationship with EOC was being considered as part of that.
Future meetings
Both the Chair and the Interland TM noted that association representation had been better at the virtual AGMs in 2020 and 2021 than at recent in-person meetings.
Simon Greenwood (SEOA) suggested that virtual meetings could be difficult to chair if the number of attendees increased and if there were contentious issues.
Debby Warren (NEOA) noted the ease of finding substitute attendees for virtual meetings.
The Chair indicated his preference for further virtual meetings.
The meeting closed at 8:37 pm.