Minutes of the AGM of the English Orienteering Council
held via Zoom
on Monday 30th May 2022

Present

EOC Officials
Barry Elkington Chair
Harriet Lawson Treasurer
Scott Collier Secretary
Caroline Louth Chair, Junior Selectors
Andy Hemsted Chair, Veterans Selectors
John Rye Interland Team Manager
Voting Association Representatives
Jon Wheatcroft SCOA
Simon Greenwood SEOA
Richard Lewis WMOA
Hilary Palmer EMOA
Peter Woods EAOA
Ian Marshall YHOA
Stephen Round NWOA
Duncan Archer NEOA
Actions: Responsible:
The Treasurer undertook to monitor the level of reserves over the next year and report back at the next AGM. Treasurer

The Treasurer undertook to circulate a revised forecast, taking account of the increased travel rates. Treasurer
Association representatives to communicate the 2022 financial contribution levels back to their Associations. Association representatives
Association representatives to advertise the upcoming Interland Team Manage vacancy within their Associations. Association representatives
John Rye (Interland TM), in collaboration with the relevant TMs, to revise the guidelines given to organising clubs on accommodation provision for the Home Internationals. Interland TM and TMs
Progress discussions with the other Home Nations on the proposed changes to the VHI rules regarding M/W65s and M/W70s. Chair
Discuss and agree a clear position on Interland eligibility for Juniors that can be published on the EOC website. Chair of Junior Selectors and Interland TM
In 2023 the Secretary should aim to give more notice of the meeting, avoid the school half term week, and start at 8:00 pm rather than 7:30 pm. Secretary

The meeting commenced at 7:33 pm.

Apologies
Apologies were received from:
Charlie Adams (Senior Team Manager)
Mel Elkington (Welfare Officer & Kit Officer)
Christine Vince (SWOA)

Adoption of the 2021 AGM minutes
No comments were made, and none had been received in advance of the meeting. Adoption of the minutes of the 2021 AGM was carried nem.con.

Actions arising
The actions arising from the 2021 AGM had been completed.

Chair’s report
The Chair began by welcoming attendees to the third virtual Annual General Meeting, and noted that it was pleasing once again to see such good Association representation.

All three Home Internationals had taken place in 2021, with England winning two and suffering a close defeat in the third. The Chair congratulated all the team members who ran for England, and thanked the various Team Managers and Selectors. The Chair also thanked South London Orienteers who, having staged the Junior Home International in October, then put on the Veteran Home International in December after it had been cancelled by SCOA due to access problems.

Unfortunately, the 2022 Interland event in Belgium, scheduled for April, had been cancelled. From the Belgians’ point of view the unpredictability of restrictions on the event made incurring any expenses a financial risk they were not willing to take. The Chair hoped that Interland will finally take place again in 2023.

Despite the lack of an event, the Interland Team Manager John Rye had been busy, handling all the conversations with the Belgian organisers as well as finalising the future rota for the staging of the Home Internationals up until 2035. The new rota took into account that countries and regions vary with the resources they have available, both members and terrain. The scheduling of these events was now in the hands of Mike Cope and the British Orienteering Event Scheduling Group, with dates and clubs already in the fixtures list for 2023, and dates and countries/regions for 2024.

A potential conflict had been spotted for the year 2034 when Northern Ireland was down for both the Junior Inter-Regionals and the Junior Home International. However, John and Mike appeared to have agreed that that was something that could be fixed in the future, long after they would both have retired from their current roles.

After the issues with the 2021 VHI, the Chair highlighted his concern with ensuring that the clubs staging a Home International event actually understand what they have to do.

There had been a number of retirements from the Team Managers and Selectors in the last year. Junior Team Manager Nev Myers, Veteran Team Manager Sarah Brown, and Chair of Junior Selectors Keith Marsden had all stood down after many years of service, and the Chair thanked them for all their work on behalf of the EOC.

The Chair concluded by hoping that he would have a full set of events to report on in twelve months’ time, and by looking forward to a successful year for all English teams.

Home Internationals

  • Ward Junior HI (Hindhead Common & the Devil’s Punch Bowl Individual; Bramshott Common Relay, SLOW SEOA) – results:
  England Ireland Scotland Wales
Individual 80 35 74 26
Relays 52 24 52 14
Total 132 59 126 40
  • Senior HI (Glen Tanar Individual; Balmedie Relay – Aberdeenshire, Scotland):
  England Ireland Scotland Wales
Individual 23 10 29 10
Relays 25 4 27 4
Total 48 14 56 14
  • Veteran HI (Winterfold & Pitch Hill Individual; Glovers Wood Relay, SLOW SEOA):
  England Ireland Scotland Wales
Individual 162 61 102 85
Relays 124 40 98 48
Total 286 101 200 133

Dates of all 2022 Home Internationals have now been fixed in the autumn and can be found on the EOC website.

When it is England’s turn to host an HI the responsibility rests on the designated region and the roster is on the EOC website. In 2022 the SCOA are scheduled to host the SHI.

Adoption of the 2021 financial accounts
The statement of accounts for 2021 and a forecast for 2022 had been circulated ahead of the meeting. The 2021 accounts had been reviewed by Paul Young of EMOA.

The Treasurer noted that the format of the accounts had changed from previous years to try to future-proof them. Electronic banking had now been adopted to enable prompt paying of expenses.

Income was slightly up as Interland did not go ahead, and this had been factored into the 2022 forecast. The JHIs had been over budget by 14%, but some of this had been recouped after SLOW took on VHIs at short notice.

Stephen Round (NWOA) noted that the cash reserves looked strong and asked what level of reserves EOC required. The Treasurer confirmed that the current level of reserves were appropriate given forecast expenditure for Interland travel and accommodation.

The Interland TM suggested that EOC should aim to reduce cash reserves to around £5k by the end of December 2023, keeping Association contributions consistent year-to-year. Duncan Archer (NEOA) suggested that it would be more appropriate to set a reserves target as a percentage of turnover, rather than as an absolute cash figure.

The Chair noted that expenditure in 2021 had been much lower than usual, with no Interland and two HIs in Southern England.

The Treasurer indicated that it was difficult to predict future cost increases given the current rate of inflation, particularly in fuel costs, and undertook to monitor the level of reserves over the next year and report back at the next AGM.

Action: Treasurer

The adoption of the 2021 accounts was proposed by Harriet Lawson (Treasurer), seconded by Hilary Palmer (EMOA), and carried nem.con.

Appointment of a reviewer for the 2022 financial accounts
Paul Young, the EMOA Treasurer, who had reviewed the 2021 accounts, kindly agreed to perform the same role for the 2022 accounts ahead of the 2023 AGM. His reappointment was proposed by Harriet Lawson (Treasurer), seconded by Simon Greenwood (SEOA), and carried nem.con.

Approval of the Association and athlete financial contributions for 2022
The Treasurer recommended that the Association financial contribution for 2022 be set at 85p per head, and that the athlete contributions be as follows:

JHI SHI VHI Interland
£110 £90 £100 £120

There was a discussion of whether mileage rates should be increased to reflect inflation. The Secretary clarified that the current British Orienteering mileage rate was 25p per mile plus 2p per passenger. Duncan Archer (NEOA) asked whether a small increase in the mileage rates would have a material impact on the budget. The Treasurer was content that it would not.

Following discussion, it was proposed that the mileage rates should be increased to 14p per mile for one team member, 25p per mile for two team members and 32p per mile for three team members, and that the flight and train cap should be increased to £60.

There was then a discussion about whether to use the current cash reserves to avoid an increase in the Association contribution. Hilary Palmer (EMOA) indicated that small incremental rises in the contribution would be preferable to larger unpredictable rises in future, while Jon Wheatcroft (SCOA) and Simon Greenwood (SEOA) indicated that their Associations would be content with the proposed increase to 85p per head.

The athlete and Association contributions as recommended by the Treasurer and the increased travel rates proposed following the preceding discussion were proposed by Peter Woods (EAOA), seconded by Ian Marshall (YHOA), and agreed nem.con.

The Treasurer undertook to circulate a revised forecast, taking account of the increased travel rates.

Action: Treasurer

The Chair requested that Association representatives communicate the 2022 contribution levels back to their Associations.

Action: Association representatives

The Chair thanked the Treasurer for her efforts in her first year in the role.

England Orienteering kit
The Secretary read out a report on behalf of the Kit Officer.

Since the previous AGM the EOC had sold 18 O-tops, 10 hoodies, one sweatshirt, two t-shirts and three technical t-shirts for the Home Internationals (Interland not having taken place).

EOC held a good level of stock and it was unlikely that any additional kit or badges would need to be purchased this year. Hence no expenditure was forecast for 2022.

Election of officers
The Chair, Treasurer and Secretary indicated that they were content to continue in post.

Barry Elkington (WMOA) was proposed as Chair, Scott Collier (SWOA) as Secretary and Harriet Lawson (WMOA) as Treasurer. The appointments were proposed by Caroline Louth (Chair of Junior Selectors), seconded by Duncan Archer (NEOA), and carried nem.con.

Appointment of Selectors, Team Managers, and other officials
Since the previous AGM:

  • Keith Marsden (SEOA) had retired as Chair of Junior Selectors and Caroline Louth (EAOA) had been appointed as his successor.
  • Simon Kippin (SCOA) had been appointed to the Junior Selection Panel.
  • Sarah Brown (SEOA) had retired as Veteran Team Manager after over 20 years and Amanda Crawshaw (YHOA) had been appointed as her successor.
  • Nev Myers (YHOA) had retired as Junior Team Manager and Katherine Bett (SCOA) and Will Heap (SEOA) had jointly been appointed as his successors.

The Chair thanked those retiring for their service and thanked their successors for taking on the roles.

All other officials had agreed to continue in post, and their reappointment was approved nem.con.

John Rye (SWOA) had previously indicated that he planned to retire as Interland Team Manager following the 2023 event in Belgium. He noted that it would clearly be beneficial to the handover if his successor was on the 2023 trip and that previous experience of Interland, as a parent or a competitor, would be helpful but was not essential.

The Chair requested that Association representatives advertise the upcoming Interland Team Manage vacancy within their Associations.

Action: Association representatives

Composition of the VHI team
A proposal had been discussed with David May (WOA) to add a second M/W65 and two M/W70s to each Home Nation team for the VHI.

This proposal would result in two additional relay teams per Home Nation. Work was in progress by Rob Hickling (SOA) to develop reviewed relay team combinations.

The Chair indicated that other associations had been sounded out about whether increasing the number of 65s and 70s would make it difficult to raise a team, and it had been agreed that it would not.

The Chair of Veterans Selectors noted that increasing numbers might make finding suitable accommodation more challenging. This led to a discussion about the expectations on organising clubs for the provision of accommodation. Duncan Archer (NEOA) suggested that the guidance given to organising clubs on this had been inconsistent.

John Rye (Interland TM) took an action, in collaboration with the relevant TMs, to revise the guidelines given to organising clubs on accommodation provision for the Home Internationals.

Action: Interland TM

The Interland TM queried who had the authority to agree to the proposed change to the VHI rules. The Chair clarified that the proposal had the support of all four VHI TMs.

It was agreed, nem.con. that the Chair could take forward discussions with the other Home Nations on the proposed changes to the VHI rules.

Action: Chair

Caroline Louth (Chair of Junior Selectors) queried the eligibility rules for England teams for Interland, and whether it was aligned with eligibility for the HIs. The Interland TM clarified that that was the established practice, although Interland was technically an inter-federation competition.

The Chair of Junior Selectors) and Interland TM undertook to discuss and agree a clear position on Interland eligibility that could be published on the EOC website.

Action: Chair of Junior Selectors and Interland TM

AOB
Duncan Archer (NEOA) indicated that the Orienteering Foundation had funds available for well-reasoned and innovative projects, which could include enhancements to a Home International. Various grants had been given in the past in support of the JHIs, including to NIOA in 2019.

Future meetings
It was agreed that in 2023 the Secretary should aim to give more notice of the meeting, avoid the school half term week, and start at 8:00 pm rather than 7:30 pm.

Action: Secretary