Minutes of the AGM of the English Orienteering Council
held via Zoom
on Monday 20th May 2024

Present

EOC Officials
Barry Elkington Chair
Harriet Lawson Treasurer
Scott Collier Secretary
Caroline Louth Chair, Junior Selectors
Will Heap Junior Team Manager
John Duckworth Senior Selector
Martin Ward Chair, Senior Selectors
John Rye Interland Team Manager
Voting Association Representatives
Christine Vince SWOA
Simon Moore SCOA
Richard Lewis WMOA
Paul Young EMOA
Barbara Beckett/Paul Beckett EAOA
Ian Marshall/Nev Myers YHOA
Stella Lewsley NWOA
Boris Spence NEOA
Actions: Responsible:
Check that the clubs staging HIs understand what their responsibilities are and offer assistance if required. Association representatives
Encourage potential candidates for a Senior Selector vacancy to discuss this with Martin Ward. Association representatives
Refrain from sending out requests for athlete contributions for Interland prior to January. Interland Team Manager
Arrange for the athlete contributions, mileage rates and expense limits to be posted on a separate page on the website. Secretary
Assist with identifying a new reviewer for the accounts from the 2025 AGM onwards. Association representatives
Assist with identifying candidates to take over as Secretary from the 2025 AGM. Association representatives

The meeting commenced at 8:03pm.

Apologies
Apologies had been received from:
Mel Elkington (Welfare Officer & Kit Officer)
Nick Barrable (Senior Team Manager)
Andy Hemsted (Chair, Veteran Selectors)

Adoption of the 2023 AGM minutes
No comments were made, and none had been received in advance of the meeting. Adoption of the minutes of the 2023 AGM was proposed by Boris Spence (NEOA), seconded by Christine Vince (SWOA) and carried nem con.

Actions arising
The actions arising from the 2023 AGM had been completed.

Paul Beckett (EAOA) confirmed that preparations were well in hand for JHI 2024, but noted the increasing financial risk for associations of hosting the Home Internationals events, particularly with respect to accommodation costs.

Chair’s report
The Chair began by welcoming attendees to the EOC’s fifth virtual Annual General Meeting and noted that it was once again pleasing to see a good Regional representation.

The Chair noted the sad passing of two great supporters of the England teams in the past year.

The EOC owed much to Keith Marsden for all his work both as a Junior Team Manager for many years, and Chair of the Junior Selection Panel for even longer. Besides that, and alongside his GB Junior leadership, the Marsden team had been a key driver in Happy Herts’ smooth and successful organisation of two Interlands. Keith, if asked, had offered wise counsel both to subsequent England Junior Team Managers and to predecessor EOC chairs.

The EOC was also indebted to Helen Gristwood, who managed the England team kit for more than a decade, modernised its design, procurement and economic provision, organised England’s Interland victuals and, with Philip as EOC Chair, allowed their ‘Woking cottage’ to be used as an Interland rendezvous point for many years. They would both be much missed.

The Chair noted that this was only the second year since taking over as Chair that he had had a full set of events to report on, with all three Home Internationals taking place in 2023, and a visit to Belgium for Interland in March 2024. There were victories for England’s Junior and Veteran teams at the Home Internationals, while the Seniors had been runners-up behind Scotland, although only after applying the fiendish John-Rye-inspired tie-break rules. At Interland, the England team had managed to reverse 2023’s defeat in the overall competition by the Belgian federation Orienteering Vlaanderen (OV), gaining the upper-hand to reclaim the Interland Cup, with the Juniors successfully retaining the Junior Trophy. The Chair congratulated all the team members who were selected and ran for England, and thanked the various Team Managers and Selectors for their contribution to the teams’ successes. The Chair also thanked the South West and West Midlands OAs, who hosted the Veteran and Junior Home Internationals respectively.

Dates and clubs for the 2024 Home Internationals were in the British Orienteering fixture list. The Seniors were due to travel to Scotland and the Veterans to Northern Ireland, whilst the Juniors would be at home for a weekend in October hosted by the East Anglia OA. In 2025, England were due to host the Senior HIs in the North West, whilst the Juniors were due to travel to Wales and the Veterans to Scotland. Interland 2025 was to be hosted in the Drenthe region of the Netherlands (south west of Assen) by the Nederlandse Orienteringsloop Bond (NOLB). Once again, the Chair asked the representative for each Region hosting a Home International to check that the clubs staging the event understand what their responsibilities are and offer assistance if required.

Action: Association representatives

In discussion with the other Home Nations, it had been agreed to change the VHI rules to include additional M/W65s and M/W70s. The team size was to remain at twenty-four, which all the nations had wanted, and this had been achieved by removing the single M/W35s (expecting them to compete as M/W21s in the SHIs, as they are often good enough), and one of each of the M/W40s. These would be replaced by a second representative of each of the M/W65 age classes, and one representative from each of M/W70. The Chair noted that this would allow the older orienteers in our community to continue to fight for a place to represent their country.

There had been a number of changes or proposed changes to the Team Managers and Selectors over the past year. John Rye had retired as Team Manager for Interland (at his second attempt), a role that he has performed for many, many years. John Duckworth had agreed to take on this challenge, and as a result was standing down as a Senior Selector. Richard Robinson had agreed to fill the vacancy thus created.

Charlie Adams had stood down as Senior Team Manager and Nick Barrable had taken over. The Chair noted that Nick had plenty of experience of competing at this level, and expressed his thanks to both John and Charlie, and to their replacements.

Looking forward, Martin Ward had indicated his desire to step down from the Senior Selection panel. The Chair asked that Association representatives encourage anyone who might be interested in becoming a Senior Selector to talk to Martin to learn what would be involved.

Action: Association representatives

John Rye had continued his work to bring up to date and improve the content of the Rules and Guidelines for the three Home Internationals. These now contained both the Competition Rules and some Guidelines for those hosting the event. They are all to be found on the Competition Rules page of the BOF web site. With agreement from the other National Federations, John had also updated the Interland course planning guidelines to provide equal winning times for Men and Women.

Duncan Birtwistle had set up an @englandorienteering Instagram account, which the Chair encouraged people to follow.

The Chair concluded by thanking the Secretary and Treasurer for their support over the past year, as well as John Cooke and Tim Holt as the web master and developer, and Melanie Elkington as Kit and Welfare Officer, and by looking forward to a successful 2024/25.

Home Internationals

  • Ward Junior HI (Sutton Park, Individual & Relay – West Midlands, England):
  England Ireland Scotland Wales
Individual 77 41 72 23
Relays 58 24 46 10
Total 135 65 118 33
  • Senior HI (Merthyr Common Individual; Clydach Terrace Relay – South Wales) – results:
  England Ireland Scotland Wales
Individual 26 11 26 8
Relays 26 4 26 10
Total 52 15 52 18

With scores equal in both the Individual and Relay races, the tiebreak rules had been used to decide on a winner. First the number of team wins across the relay and individual, which was equal on 3 each. Next the number of individual wins: 2 each. Next the number of team second places: equal again. Finally the number of individual 2nd places determined the result with Scotland having 3 to England’s 1.

  • Veteran HI (Mallards Pike, Individual & Relay – Forest of Dean, England) – results:
  England Ireland Scotland Wales
Individual 157 70 115 81
Relays 126 52 78 56
Total 283 122 193 137

When it is England’s turn to host an HI the responsibility rests on the designated Region and the roster is on the EOC website. In 2025 the NWOA are scheduled to host the SHI.

Interland
Interland 2024 was hosted by the Belgian federation – Fédération Régionale des Sports d’Orientation (FRSO) – at Habay-la-Neuve in the Ardennes. England regained the Interland Cup and successfully retained the Junior Trophy.

  OV NOLB LHFCO LUXOC FRSO ENG
Grand Total 205 36 140 170 88 222
Position 2 6 4 3 5 1
Junior Trophy 70 8 59 53 21 82
Position 2 6 3 4 5 1

Interland 2025 is to be hosted in the Drenthe region of the Netherlands (south west of Assen) on March 2nd by the Nederlandse Orienteringsloop Bond (NOLB).

Adoption of the 2023 financial accounts
The Treasurer referred to the report and statement of accounts that had been previously circulated.

The Treasurer thanked Paul Young (EMOA) for again carrying out the independent review of the accounts.

Overall income for the year was as anticipated despite a number of athletes making alternative travel arrangements. Expenditure was £2k less than forecasted, most likely as a result of cautious over-forecasting on the basis of 2022.

The forecast for 2024 had been circulated and showed, for comparison, both the 2023 forecast and 2023 actuals.

There had been a decrease in the overall cash balance since 2022 due to the purchase of around £3k of kit in January 2023. As of the date of the AGM, there was around £6,300 in the bank, which was around £1k lower than at the date of the 2023 AGM.

Based on current cash holdings and the unpredictability of travel costs, the Treasurer believed that the current forecast for 2024 was appropriate.

Some challenges had been encountered in reconciling year-end contributions due to some team members paying for Interland 2024 in December 2023. The Treasurer asked that the Interland Team Manager request selected team members not to pay their athlete contribution until January.

Action: Interland Team Manager

The Interland Team Manager queried whether SEOA had paid their 2023 Association contribution. The Treasurer confirmed that they had done so.

Stella Lewsley (NWOA) complimented the Treasurer on the clarity of the accounts.

The adoption of the 2023 accounts was proposed by the Treasurer, seconded by Martin Ward (Chair, Senior Selectors) and carried nem con.

Appointment of a reviewer for the 2024 financial accounts
Paul Young, the EMOA Treasurer, who had reviewed the 2023 accounts, kindly agreed to perform the same role for the 2024 accounts ahead of the 2025 AGM, but indicated that this would be his final year of doing so. His reappointment was proposed by Christine Vince (SWOA), seconded by Barbara Beckett (EAOA) and carried nem con.

The Chair asked that Association representatives assist with identifying a new reviewer for the accounts from the 2025 AGM onwards.

Action: Association representatives

Approval of the 2024 Association and athlete financial contributions

The Treasurer noted that there had been a significant increase in athletes making alternative arrangements for travel or accommodation, primarily at the Senior and Veteran Home Internationals. The EOC did not have a clear policy on what athletes should be charged in these circumstances. In 2023, athletes who chose not to use the transport and accommodation arranged by EOC had not paid that portion of the fee, only the costs of entering the event, but had then not been permitted to claim expenses. If the original accommodation is non-refundable, this could leave EOC out of pocket.

The Treasurer suggested that there were three options:

  1. Require all athletes to use the travel and accommodation arranged by EOC unless there were exceptional circumstances
  2. Decline to reimburse athletes for alternative arrangements
  3. Reimburse athletes for alternative arrangements

Stella Lewsley (NWOA) queried whether the Association representatives had been given sufficient notice to form a view on this.

John Rye (Interland Team Manager) proposed that the Team Manager for each competition should be given delegated authority to manage the finances in respect of athlete contributions and travel and accommodation costs.

Martin Ward (Chair, Senior Selectors) raised the ongoing difficulty of raising a full-strength team, particular for the Senior Home International. He proposed given athletes the choice up front of paying a fixed amount including accommodation or an alternative amount without accommodation.

Paul Young (EMOA) proposed refunds should be shared depending on costs

After discussion, the meeting agreed that athletes should be expected to travel and stay with the team, to maximise team morale at the event. All athletes should pay the specified personal contribution. In exceptional circumstances, such as where an athlete was staying at home or travelling with their whole family, then athletes may be refunded a portion of their personal contribution, by negotiation with the relevant Team Manager and the Treasurer, and with travel expenses forming part of that discussion.

The Treasurer noted that the Team Manager contribution was usually set at a third of the athlete contribution, unless the Team Manager had also been selected as part of the team, in which case they would pay the full athlete contribution. Paul Young (EMOA), Nev Myers (YHOA) and Stella Lewsley (NWOA) queried whether this was fair, given the effort required to act as a Team Manager, and whether it was necessary given the relatively small amount of money involved. Paul Young (EMOA) proposed that Team Managers should not be required to pay any fee at competitions where they had not been selected as part of the team. Nev Myers (YHOA) seconded this and it was agreed nem con.

[Post-meeting note: The discussion at the meeting was inconclusive as to what fee (if any) a Team Manager should pay when they have been selected as part of the team, a situation which is realistically only likely to arise in respect of the VHI or Interland. The Officers subsequently agreed that the Team Manager should also pay no fee in those circumstances, noting that this position could be revisited at the 2025 AGM if required.]

The Treasurer recommended that the Association financial contribution for 2024 be set at 85p per head, and that the athlete contributions be as follows:

JHI SHI VHI Interland
£120 £90 £100 £120

The Treasurer also recommended that mileage rates and travel expense limits should stay the same:

Mileage rates per mile

1 team member in vehicle 14p
2 team members in vehicle 25p
3 team members in vehicle 32p
each additional team member 2p

Flight/train cap (including parking and luggage expenses)
£60

It was agreed that the athlete contributions, mileage rates and expense limits should be posted on a separate page on the EOC website for increased visibility.

Action: Secretary

The Treasurer confirmed that she was still awaiting membership numbers from British Orienteering before sending out requests for 2024 Association contributions.

The approval of the 2024 Association and athlete financial contributions was proposed by the Treasurer, seconded by Stella Lewsley (NWOA) and carried nem con.

Paul Young noted that the budget for 2024 would require amending to reflect the removal of Team Manager contributions. This was agreed nem con.

Kit Officer’s report
The Chair read out a report on behalf of the Kit Officer.

The Kit Officer reported that the EOC held a good level of kit in stock, and that it was likely that some more Women’s O-tops would need to be purchased in 2024/5.

Since the previous AGM, the EOC had sold twenty-nine O-tops, fourteen hoodies, two t-shirts, two sweatshirts and five technical t-shirts, mostly to the Juniors.

The Chair thanked the Kit Officer for her efforts.

Constitutional status of the EOC and proposed next steps

The Treasurer noted that she was awaiting British Orienteering’s guidance to clubs on their corporation tax liability. The Secretary confirmed that British Orienteering was unlikely to be in a position to fund bespoke tax advice for the EOC.

The Treasurer confirmed that she was more comfortable with the EOC’s status now that the memorandum of understanding with British Orienteering was in place and had been accepted by the bank. No further progress had been made on whether to register EOC as a charity.

Election of Officers
The Chair, Treasurer and Secretary indicated that they were content to continue in post until the 2025 AGM. The Secretary indicated that he did not intend to continue in post beyond the 2025 AGM.

The Chair asked that Association representatives assist with identifying candidates to take over as Secretary from the 2025 AGM. The Secretary noted that the role was not unduly onerous and primarily consisted of arranging the papers and taking the minutes for the AGM.

Action: Association representatives

Barry Elkington (WMOA) was proposed as Chair, Scott Collier (SWOA) as Secretary and Harriet Lawson (WMOA) as Treasurer. The appointments were proposed by Barbara Beckett (EAOA), seconded by Nev Myers (YHOA) and carried nem con.

Appointment of Selectors, Team Managers, and other officials
The Chair noted that Richard Robinson had joined the Senior Selection Panel

All other officials had agreed to continue in post, and their reappointment was proposed by Boris Spence (NEOA), seconded by Ian Marshall (YHOA) and carried nem con.

AOB

Will Heap (Junior Team Manager) queried whether any guidance was available on how quickly selections should be made following the final selection race. The Chair confirmed that this should be set out in the relevant selection policy.

Martin Ward (Chair, Senior Selectors) suggested that the EOC should consider introducing a maximum term of office for officials.

John Rye (Interland Team Manager) noted that this was his last EOC AGM and expressed his thanks to the Treasurers (Judith Wingham, Glynis Wheatcroft, Catherine Galvin, Leslie Ross, and Harriet Lawson) and Chairs (Jon Wheatcroft, Philip Gristwood, and Barry Elkington) he had served with over the years.

The Chair thanked John for his many years of service as a Team Manager for both Interland and the Senior Home International.

Future meetings
The meeting agreed that the 2025 AGM should take place on Monday 2nd June at 8:00pm.

The meeting closed at 9:34pm.